Dining options in downtown Shelbyville are dwindling.
Blue River Bistro & Bar, 39 Public Square, announced in late November it would be shutting down with the intent of finding a new location.
On Wednesday, Pudder’s at 18 Public Square, posted an announcement on Facebook that it will close on Dec. 31.
“After many years of serving exceptional meals to the community, Pudders has made the difficult decision to close its doors permanently. This decision, while filled with mixed emotions, comes as the result of personal reasons as well as a challenging economic climate.”
Pudder’s was originally created by the Phares family that owns and operates the St. Paul Tavern. The restaurant survived the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. Val and Alicia Phares then sold the restaurant to Bryan and Kim Rice (photo), who made the announcement Wednesday.
“We are grateful for the support we have received throughout the years, and we want to extend our heartfelt thanks to every guest, staff member, and partner who has been part of our journey. We also want to extend a very heartfelt thank you to our daughter, Madison, who has been a tremendous part in the day-to-day operations of the restaurant. Everyone’s loyalty and dedication have meant the world to us, and we will cherish these memories for years to come.”
The Shelby County Post is a digital newspaper producing news, sports, obituaries and more without a pay wall or subscription needed.
Indiana state forests to offer open houses
Driver injured in Friday crash into a tree
Benefit ride for Alisha Reynolds on October 24
Former Roachdale Town Marshal sentenced to probation
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance announces 2027 summer internship program
Read your FEMA letter carefully
Road closure to impact U.S. 36 in Parke and Putnam counties
South Vermillion to honor fallen mom all season
BMV branches closed for Labor Day weekend
New traffic pattern to impact State Road 63 near Newport
Riddell National Bank makes new scoreboard reality for Parke Heritage
Riverton Parke to remember fallen player
Rockville man arrested after setting fires
Governor Braun delivers another month of gas savings for Hoosier families
Find a cooling center near you with Indiana 211
2026 Indiana State Fair celebrates Hoosier spirit, summer fun and memories made
State health officials and emergency healthcare providers agree to discontinue routine hospital diversion
Heat Advisory in effect through Thursday evening
