indy-man-arrested-at-horseshoe-indianapolis-after-gas-station-robbery
An Indianapolis man accused of stealing money at a gas station was arrested at Horseshoe Indianapolis in Shelbyville.
On Wednesday, Fishers police arrested Michael Schupay, 34, on charges of robbery and theft.
Just before 6 a.m., Fishers officers responded to the report of a robbery at the Circle K gas station located at 9611 Allisonville Road, just north of East 96th Street. Police say the accused threatened to shoot the employee. He stole an undisclosed amount of money.
The employee was able to call 911 after the accused fled the scene. The employee was unharmed during the incident.
Surveillance video from the gas station provided a suspect vehicle description. Fishers police then utilized the FLOCK/License Plate Reader (LPR) camera system and located a suspect vehicle. It was tracked down in the Shelbyville area at the Horseshoe Casino.
With the assistance of the Shelbyville Police Department and Indiana Gaming Commission, Schupay was taken into custody and detained until Fishers police detectives arrived to continue the investigation. Upon interviewing Schupay he admitted to the robbery.
A search of Schupay’ s vehicle located U.S. currency consistent with that stolen from the Circle K and items of clothing consistent with that worn during the robbery.
Schupay was transported and booked into the Hamilton County Jail on robbery - Level 5 Felony and theft - Class A Misdemeanor.
The Shelby County Post is a digital newspaper producing news, sports, obituaries and more without a pay wall or subscription needed. Get the most recent Shelby County Post headlines delivered to your email by visiting shelbycountypost.com and click on the free daily email signup link at the top of the page.
Former Roachdale Town Marshal sentenced to probation
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance announces 2027 summer internship program
Gov. Braun extends tax filing deadline for Hoosiers impacted by August storms
Read your FEMA letter carefully
Road closure to impact U.S. 36 in Parke and Putnam counties
South Vermillion to honor fallen mom all season
BMV branches closed for Labor Day weekend
New traffic pattern to impact State Road 63 near Newport
Riddell National Bank makes new scoreboard reality for Parke Heritage
Riverton Parke to remember fallen player
Rockville man arrested after setting fires
Governor Braun delivers another month of gas savings for Hoosier families
$120M granted to Indiana to improve healthcare access
Find a cooling center near you with Indiana 211
2026 Indiana State Fair celebrates Hoosier spirit, summer fun and memories made
State health officials and emergency healthcare providers agree to discontinue routine hospital diversion
Heat Advisory in effect through Thursday evening
USDA offers disaster assistance to Ag producers in Indiana impacted by recent flooding
First Indiana human case of West Nile found in Allen County
Legendary 'Indiana Rangers' receive Presidential Unit Citation, Sagamore of the Wabash for Vietnam War heroism
