In February 2026, the owner of the Economy Inn in Hamlet, reported a break-in to the Starke County Sheriff’s Department. At the time, the business was closed due to a prior fire.
During the investigation, it was determined that suspect(s) had forced entry into a motel room and removed copper plumbing. In March, the owner reported an additional theft of copper from the property.
Through the course of the investigation, detectives identified Nichole Patrick, 42, of Peru, as a suspect. Patrick was linked to both incidents.
On Saturday evening Saturday Starke County deputies, with assistance from the Hamlet Police Department, located Patrick at a residence in Hamlet. She was detained and transported to the Starke County Justice Center.
A report was submitted to the Starke County Prosecutor’s Office for review. Formal charges were subsequently filed, charging Patrick with Burglary - Level 5 felony, and Theft - Level 5 felony.
Indiana BMV extends hours of operation for the primary election
Indiana State Police Bremen Post Operation Blue Thunder results
Plymouth Fire Department forms 'PFD Forward' committee to address staffing and funding challenges
Plymouth Police report multiple arrests over busy weekend
Culver officer narrowly escapes injury after suspected drunk driver sideswipes patrol car
Rochester man arrested in Plymouth on multiple charges following theft investigation
Marshall County Historical Society to Feature Ben Franklin in Next "America’s 250" Brown Bag Lecture
National Train Day at Hoosier Valley Railroad Museum
