An hour of discussion surrounding flock cameras during the November Greencastle City Council meeting will result in more discussions slated amongst city officials.
Last month, a resident approached the Greencastle City Council with concerns about the use of Flock cameras around the city, and Mayor Lynda Dunbar opted to put the discussion on the agenda for November.
The discussion generated quite a few talking points from Greencastle Police Chief Christopher Jones, council members and residents.
The discussion, while informative, will lead to further discussions, according to Dunbar.
"What will happen next is Chief Jones and I will sit down with the city attorney and council members to discuss it further and how we want to move forward with this. I want to point out our website has all this information under police," Dunbar stated.
Jones told those in attendance his department became interested in the technology around 2021 and a contract was signed in 2023 with Flock.
"We have four cameras up on major roadways as kind of a safety net that we can use for investigative purposes. We are a small department, so we try to use whatever we can to try and solve our crimes. These are starter cameras. They are not live cameras. It did take us about three years to get them all implemented because there is a training and permitting purpose. Once the cameras got put up, there was a lot of social media and internet stuff about flock and privacy issues. We had a camera stolen and taken down," Jones told those in attendance.
Jones looked to dismiss several misconceptions with the cameras, stating they do not do facial recognition, cannot identify a driver, passenger or run radar.
"They don't do facial recognition and are only programmed to read or take a snap shot of a license plate when it passes that camera. When a car goes by, it takes a snapshot on the back of the camera and stores that image into the database for 30 days. All that information is purged from the system. It doesn't do speed, observe passengers, drivers, race or gender. That information is never recalled unless an officer needs it at a later time during that 30 days," the veteran chief said.
Jones said he has seen the stories and inaccurate information on social media and the internet.
"I wish they did half the stuff I've read on the internet, we'd solve a lot more crimes," he said.
The cameras have been beneficial to the Greencastle Police and have aided in several crimes, according to Jones.
"We have found a missing person, person in an assault case, several stolen cars, person who had 20-plus child crimes and solved hit and runs. We have a transparency page where you can see the number of searches we have conducted. There is a lot of good news. Yes, there are officers who have abused the Flock and there is a handful out of the thousands and thousands of officers," Jones said.
Jones was asked if there was a timeframe on getting the one sign replaced that was stolen and he said, no.
"We are in discussion to get the stolen camera replaced. Took three years to get the four cameras, they are really busy. I could not tell you. Hope it's within the next six months," Jones replied.
Dunbar said a contract was established in 2023 and the use of cameras was approved before she became mayor, pointing to a prior administration.
"This product was approved before I became the mayor, but I was familiar with it. Our previous mayor and I met. We had the funding for it, and sat through a lot of meetings about how it was a good, useful tool for the police department," Dunbar said.
Several residents, however, were not convinced, pointing to how flock cameras are a violation of Constitutional rights.
Mark Palmer, a resident in Greencastle's First Ward, approached council stating that he wants Greencastle to be safe and supports giving police resources to ensure that happens, but warned council about data sharing and public transparency.
"I urge the council to cancel future flock camera contract renewals. Until then, put bags on these cameras or simply take them down for the respect of the Greencastle taxpayers who did not vote for these cameras," Palmer said.
Putnam Coutny resident Joshua Mitchell explained how he knows the ins and outs of the camera system, as he works on and builds them.
He raised concerns over the Fourth Amendment and the lack of guardrails preventing local police from obtaining a geofence warrant.
"Let me explain to you what a geofence warrant is. It is where a police department will use celluar data and if a warrant is acquired all the device from those devices gets shared to that police department. I beg to differ that it is not a Constitutional violation. Last month, the Supreme Court ruled in a 6-3 decision that use of a geofence warrant constitutes a search under the Fourth Amendment. These cameras take a picture of your license plate and you drive by these cameras and every single time you drive past one, that information is logged. There is no legal framework preventing an officer of the law from getting that information. I believe that constitutes a direction violation of the Fourth Amendment," he said.
Councilmen David Masten and Vincent Aguirre, who represent the First Ward and Fourth Ward, respectively, both voiced their concerns over the cameras.
"Council didn't approve flock cameras. Council wasn't asked. Nothing had come up until last month. I didn't even know we had them. My basic thought process on this is we are tracked everywhere we go. I just don't like it. I would be leading the charge against flock cameras except when that child gets found by one, that is when I see a use for one. That could be one in a million," Masten said.
Aguirre said he "mostly agreed" with Masten's assertion.
"I struggle with the technology and the company, not with the tool being in the police department's hands. I trust our police department. I don't trust the technology and the company and that puts me in a unique and challenging spot. I don't know the market or if there are alternative tools that can do some of the same functionality. If there are, it would be worth looking into," Aguirre said.
Emergency Alert System (EAS) nationwide test Tuesday
Gov. Braun urges veterans to claim property tax relief before January deadline
Prep your vehicle for winter weather
Conservation officers remind hunters to prioritize safety during deer season
Governor Braun extends gas tax savings
